6

There are now multiple PoE HATs available:

I need to choose which one to use for my project.

I already know from reading the product pages in detail that:

  • The Official HAT does not allow to connect other HATS without soldering because it does not pass through the pin header. The fan is said to be quite noisy.
  • The PiSupply HAT cannot do Gigabit Ethernet. (No idea if the other ones can.)
  • Using external PoE splitters (like this one) often produces the same Gigabit Ethernet problem.
  • The LoveRPi HAT is not isolated, and connecting the Pi to another grounded device like a monitor over HDMI will kill the Pi (see product description and Amazon comments).
  • Some other

Beyond this, can anybody provide or link to a proper, full comparison with pros and cons of the options new available for PoE HATs, or at least of the general approaches on which the different devices are based?

1
  • This is a real depressing list of options. I usually like to use the passive cooling options, but with any of those HATs that's not an option anymore either.
    – tcurdt
    Feb 13 at 15:56
1

Use the official one. While soldering may be a pain, it is possible. You can also replace the fan with another one.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.