0

Setup: RPi 4 with LAMP on IT sucks DK

My SD card is quite quick sure (it's a Class 10 too and all) but my question is this:

  • Would there be increased performance if I hosted my web-server files on a USB 3.0 HDD/SSD instead af my Class 10 SD-card on the Pi?

Anyone tried this yet?

EDIT: Another thought: If I want people to be able to upload and download larger than 1GB files wouldn't it be practical AND faster to be reading and writing these files to a DIR on the USB 3.0 SSD instead of the SD-card which is only 16GB all in all anyways and I do have 500/500 Mbit fiber line at my full disposal for the server?

1

USB flash drives can reach up 33MBytes/s, but there seem to be some limitations in the NAND itself so it will come down to the type of stick you get. However, the sd-card bus speed can reach up to 20MB/s read on the raspberry pi. So, the better choice here is a high-class USB 2.0 USB flash drive.

On the other hand, the payment would be concerned. It cost much less to buy USB 2.0 USB flash drive instead of a UHS-3/Class 10 sd-card.

In conclusion, I see little benefit in booting from a USB flash stick, the price, and the speed. Source

If you compare SD-Card and USB 2.0, the USB 2.0 port is much faster. Obviously, USB 3.0 has a much much faster speed. The USB 3.0 is approximately 10 times faster than USB 2.0.

You may found that SSD drives are better for hosting BUT take a look at this link.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thx... I will take a look at it tonight. – IT Blacksmith Feb 2 at 17:33
  • I found your link very informative reading - I will mark your post as answer to my question because it's so extensive :-) – IT Blacksmith Feb 2 at 22:53
1

The SDCard interface is extremely slow compared to a USB 2.0 hard disk on my RPI3Bs.

So a USB 3.0 SSD on a RPi4B is going to be even faster (USB 3.0 is faster, SSD is faster).

| improve this answer | |
  • I heard something about that the USB-controller and other controllers are one and the same and therefore one controller could have problems when dealing with both the high mbit/s on the LANinterface AND transfering files to the USB 3.0 external SSD. Is this a valid thought? – IT Blacksmith Feb 2 at 17:31
  • 2
    The USB 3.0 controller is on a PCIe v1 interface on a RPi4, so you won't have the overlapping with the ethernet problem (unlike older RPis). – Dougie Feb 2 at 18:52
  • GReat to know - thanks for clearing that up... it's been bugging me. – IT Blacksmith Feb 2 at 22:51

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.