6

If we assume a stable system, not connected to any network, and fully backed up, what damage can cutting the power do?

Obviously it's a hassle to restore an image of the card, but a fairly minor hassle. Could the card be bricked (buying a new card is a minor expense but a more significant hassle)? Could the Pi itself be damaged?

I'm going to be building a Pi+touchscreen into a piece of equipment, which will have a swicth that can cut all power, and I don't trust my users (starting with myself).

3

Over the past few years we've been pulling plugs out of hundreds of Pi's, every day sometimes multiple times a day. We did have 1 or 2 Pi's blowing up, but I sincerely doubt it had anything to do with pulling the plug.

So I wouldn't worry to do the same. Indeed, the worst that can happen is that you'll damage an SD card, which can be recovered easily by reformatting it.

But IMHO you'll need to be extremely unlucky to even get into that latter trouble.

EDIT: rough calculation: at least 100,000 plug pulls (or the equivalent by power cuts or switching off the mains).

  • Where did you get the information to calculate that? – Charlie Feb 19 '16 at 23:33
  • We have over 300 Pi's in service for digital signage. Our venues 'suffer' regular grid powercuts and most of them just switch off the power during closing hours. My rough calculation was 300 pi * 3 years * 365 days – EDP Feb 20 '16 at 4:17
  • How did it blow up? I'm curious. – PNDA Feb 28 '16 at 7:14
  • I really don't know and TBH at this extremely low failure rate I actually don't care too much either. A low cost computer with a less than 1% failure over a time span of 3 years; I'd love to see that on any (non-industrial) component. Have a look to my -ok, not completely SD-related - answer on this thread: raspberrypi.stackexchange.com/questions/38321/… – EDP Feb 28 '16 at 8:09
1

I agree with EDP, no damage should come of pulling the plug, but if you have sensitive data on the sd card, don't pull the plug(unless the OS is frozen, and nothing is happening, and nothing will happen). I only had to pull my plug twice, both times because of XBMC. Rasp bias hasn't given me any problem, nor arch Linux or Ubuntu.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.