0

I've been looking at off the shelf raspberry pi UPS/shutdown controllers. I've come up with 4 and wanted somebody to weigh in on the choices.

My use case is pretty strait forward. I want the pi to shut down gracefully when mains power is lost. I'm not fussed about any other functionality. I'm running a Pi2 - might move to a Pi3 at some point. Smaller form factor of UPS unit is nice but safe operation comes first.

Anything else I should be considering? Is the capacitor on the pisaver any safer than the lifepo4 battery for example?

Thank you raspi community :)

lifepo4weredpi3

pisaver

upspico

mopower

  • 1
    Your question has two problems it is primarily opinion based, and second shopping recommendations are explicitly off-topic per the site's FAQ – Steve Robillard Jun 15 '18 at 20:13
  • I'm trying to find the right component for an electrical project. One that doesn't explode and does it's job keeping my data uncorrupted. If you need a question it's here - What are the consequences of using a cap as opposed to a battery – totalconfusion Jun 15 '18 at 20:39
  • Possible duplicate of How do I build a UPS-like - battery backup - system? – Fabian Jun 16 '18 at 19:42
  • Well, a cap has a useful life of 20-40 years, while a typical battery is dead after 5 or 10. – Dmitry Grigoryev Jun 18 '18 at 10:54
  • I have zero experience with this so-called "Geekworm" unit, but it's a lot less expensive than the others you've listed. – Seamus Jun 18 '18 at 21:11
1

Providing continuous power to the Raspberry Pi can be accomplished in several ways:

  • line voltage UPS (large, heavy but generally useful for many line voltage devices)
  • 5V USB UPS (small, light, limited to USB devices)
  • 12V rechargeable battery with USB ports and simultaneous charge/discharge capability (medium weight and portable, provides 5V USB, 12V)

Think of UPS as a rechargeable battery that can be charged/discharged at the same time. This may give you more options when shopping. I have bought and used all of the above for different use cases with my RPi's. Considerations include:

  • size (e.g., pocket, desktop, deskside)
  • portability (travel, field)
  • voltages (5v, 12V, line)
  • capacity (amp hours)
  • indoor/outdoor (outdoor UPS should be lower voltages for safety)

The choice of brand is up to you. We do not endorse.

0

I've settled with a PiJuice HAT. https://uk.pi-supply.com/products/pijuice-standard

It's not a cheap option nor is it the right option for everyone looking for a UPS. However, it does look well designed and offers the functionality I require (Conditional soft shutdown on mains loss)

The question still stands about the safety of a a cap vs. a battery based system.

Which one might fail (explode) and, why?

Would a super-cap even offer enough juice to soft shutdown? (like offered with the Pi-Saver)

What would sit better in an industrial control unit left untended for years on end?

SD corruption is something I've dealt with and am trying to avoid with this system.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.